What are my options if I owe more than my home is worth?

You have several paths: a short sale, a loan modification, a deed in lieu of foreclosure, or simply waiting for values to recover. A short sale is often the best option when you need to sell and cannot cover the difference. It lets you close the chapter cleanly, avoid foreclosure, and move forward without a deficiency judgment in most California cases.

Will the bank approve a short sale if I am underwater?

Banks approve short sales when the homeowner demonstrates a genuine financial hardship and the offer reflects fair market value. Being underwater alone is not enough — you also need a hardship such as job loss, divorce, illness, or relocation. An experienced short sale agent can help you document your situation and negotiate directly with the lender.

Will I owe the bank the difference after a short sale?

In most California short sales, the answer is no. California's anti-deficiency laws protect homeowners who sell their primary residence through a short sale. The lender typically cannot pursue you for the remaining balance. However, second mortgages and HELOCs can be more complicated. Always confirm your specific situation with a qualified short sale agent and a tax advisor.

You Owe More Than Your Home Is Worth

Being underwater on your mortgage feels like a trap. It is not. Bay Area homeowners in this situation have real options — and a short sale is often the cleanest path forward.

Book My Free 15-Min Call

No obligation. No cost to you.

Why being underwater matters — and what it does not mean

An underwater mortgage means your loan balance is higher than your home's current market value. In the Bay Area, this happens after market corrections, after cash-out refinances, or when a homeowner bought near a peak.

Being underwater does not mean you are in foreclosure. It does not mean you have to walk away. And in California, it does not mean you will owe the bank the difference after you sell.

What it does mean is that you cannot sell through a traditional listing without bringing cash to closing — cash most homeowners do not have. That is where a short sale comes in.

Your main options when you are underwater

Short Sale

Most common

Sell your home for less than you owe with lender approval. In most California cases, the remaining balance is forgiven and you cannot be pursued for the difference.

Loan Modification

Ask the lender to change your loan terms — lower rate, extended term, or reduced principal. Works best if you want to stay in the home and can demonstrate ability to pay.

Deed in Lieu

Transfer the home directly to the lender to avoid foreclosure. Simpler than a short sale but harder to get approved, and it does not always eliminate a deficiency.

Wait It Out

If you can afford payments and the market may recover, staying put is an option. This only works if your hardship is temporary and you are not behind on payments.

When a short sale is the right move

You need to sell and cannot cover the difference at closing
You have a financial hardship — job loss, divorce, illness, relocation, or reduced income
You want to avoid foreclosure and its longer-lasting credit damage
You want to move forward without a deficiency judgment following you
You want control over the sale process, timeline, and buyer selection

Not sure if you qualify? The best way to find out is a free consultation. Learn more about how short sales work or schedule a free call.

Common questions about selling an underwater home

Related resources

Ready to understand your options?

A free 15-minute call covers your situation, your options, and whether a short sale is the right move for you.

Book My Free 15-Min Call

No obligation. No cost to you.

See all reviews onGoogle (110+)·Zillow (190+)·Realtor.com (220+)